There are few, if any, Americans that can deny that our Founding Fathers were shrewd in providing checks and balances to protect individuals against government power in the Constitution.
They saw our two-house legislature as reflecting the will of the people, but with checks and balances to prevent “the tyranny of the majority” (James Madison).
While the House with its 435 members representing the popular opinion of the nation’s voters, the Senate, with its two members per state, was visualized as a thoughtful and reflective body, like a modern think tank, where heated issues could cool somewhat and consequences could be considered before new laws were enacted.
The Constitution provides for both houses to pass legislation with a simple majority vote of those present. To prevent the “tyranny of the majority,” it also provides a method for the minority to delay a majority vote and gather support for its point of view. That method is called the ‘filibuster.’
The Constitution allows each house to set its own rules. Each piece of legislation allows a debate on the subject. Senate rules allow a Senator, or series of Senators (each yielding the floor to the next), to speak for as long as they wish on any subject they choose. The filibuster can be ended by a 3/5 or 60-Senator vote for cloture (end debate).
The 60-Senator vote is known as a supermajority.
It is also possible to end debate through a legal maneuver known as the Nuclear Option, where a Senator brings up a point of order, reminding the Senate that its rules are not being followed with the filibuster. If the presiding officer makes a ruling to uphold the point of order, and if a simple majority of the Senators vote to uphold the ruling, the debate is ended and a vote on the issue is held immediately.
Without the threat of filibuster, the Senate needs only a simple majority of 51 votes to pass legislation and uphold rulings. But when filibuster is threatened on major bills and issues, 60 votes are needed to move past debate to the vote.
The party-line divisiveness of the modern Senate has made almost all legislative issues require a supermajority to pass. Although the supermajority vote to end debate is not a bad thing, its use as a weapon in the trench warfare between parties has left the voters as victims.
An additional use of the 60-Senator vote is used to modify budgeting, authorization, as well as appropriation guidelines and restrictions.
Each year by October 1, Congress must construct a budget it can stick to, considering government income as well as expenses. It must authorize new and ongoing programs and agencies that come into being as the result of bill passage or already exist, with non-binding recommended spending levels to carry out the program’s policies. And it must pass appropriation funding bills, providing the legal authority to use funds from the U.S. Treasury.
The annual Congressional budget is simply an outline of anticipated federal spending for the coming year, setting limits on discretionary spending if everything works out according to plan. It also allows procedural points of order for bills that exceed their spending caps.
When a bill, chugging its way through the enactment process, generates a program or agency budget that will violate its Congressional appropriation, a Senator may raise a point of order. That appropriation point can be waived by a 60-Senator vote.
On the saving side of the government ledger, the Congressional budget resolution may include a “reconciliation” figure. This is assigned to a congressional committee with directions to produce legislation that lowers spending by that amount.
Passage of a reconciliation bill is an express train with a limit of 20 hours of debate and only a majority of Senate votes for enactment.
We may learn more about reconciliation in the near future, with pressure building in Congress to pass a health reform bill and the recent upset in Massachusetts, where Republican Scott Brown was elected to serve out the remainder of Senator Ted Kennedy’s term, ending in 2012. Although a proponent of health care reform, Brown has come out against President Obama’s health care plan in its present form as fiscally unsound.
With the health care reform bill now in the merging process between House and Senate, we can be sure the 60-Senator rule will be in place, and the Democrats are now one Senator short of the necessary 60 votes for their plan.
Options for passage of the health care reform bill in some form include
- convincing at least one Republican to vote their way
- scaling down or revising the plan to make it more agreeable to opponents
- requesting the House to pass the Senate bill intact
- using the reconciliation process to pass budget item portions of the bill (that will expire in either five or ten years)
As aggravating and as slow as the Senate process is using the 60-Senator hurdle, perhaps James Madison was right. Perhaps it does protect us.
My personal opinion is that this article is terrific. I agree with much of the information you’ve provided and I’m interested in reading more articles written by you. Good job!
I wouldn’t dispute the original thoughts in your interesting article. I think your content is of great quality, smart and it really drive readers to think. I like your ideas.
I wanted to take a moment to say thank you for writing and sharing this informative article. You make interesting points that I agree with in many ways. I’m really impressed with your writing technique.
Your insight in this matter is great. I agree with much of what you have to say and your writing has caused me to think. Thank you for this info.
This original content is out of the ordinary. I appreciate that you’ve gone off the beaten path with your points and I agree with most.
Typically, I find this type of information very dull, but you made it interesting to me. This took me in and made me really think about the things you wrote. I really like this article.
I’m sure you intended your article to be thought-provoking, and it is. I have been mulling over many of your points in this article and I agree on many. Thanks.
I read many badly written articles these days. This article is a breath of fresh air. It’s nice to see you care about what and how you present your views.
Amazing stuff.
Your article is thought-provoking which is one of my favorite kinds of writing. You are obviously an accomplished writer, and if not, you should be.
While reading the article, I could envision the writer sitting alone thinking. I can tell that you worked very hard on this article. Thank you.
Up until now, all I have read on this article is extremely boring, and seems to be written by writers that lack education. You’ve done a very good job conveying your passion with accurate information.
Thank you for writing unique and interesting content. This is a very informative article. I concur with a lot of your views in this writing.
Thanks for providing this valuable and quality content. Your writing style is impressive and unique. I enjoyed reading your article and agree on many points.
It’s very nice to find out other writers share like minds on some content. This is the case with your article. I really enjoyed this.
Thank you so for sharing this useful information. I agree on many of the points of interest you are featuring. Some ideas may require some further review, but I can certainly see where you stand.
You have written a very nice article here. Even though I don’t agree with every point you make, I do agree with the overall content.
I don’t consider myself a big thinker, but your article has triggered my thought processes. Thank you for your great content. I truly appreciate it.
Keep up the great work!
You have written an amazing article with many valid, unique points that are interesting and thought-provoking. It excites me to read informative content written by a writer who is so obviously knowledgeable in this area.
Writing about what one believes in as well as you have here is impressive. You had my attention from the beginning. You have a great grasp of the points you made. I appreciate your passion.
More and more writings just have words in them that mean little to nothing. You have written an article that is very deep in meaning and kept it simple for the average reader to understand.
Thanks for all this information. I think you make very valid points and I appreciate them and agree with you. You’ve done a great job with expressing yourself in words.
Up until now, all I have read on this article is extremely boring, and seems to be written by writers that lack education. You’ve done a very good job conveying your passion with accurate information.
I like to read an article that express interesting views. Many points the author made are unique and are things I wouldn’t have thought about.
Thank you for this interesting content. Your views have given me cause to reconsider some of my preconceived notions. You have changed my mind. That’s what I call persuasive writing.
Interesting articles on information like this is a great find. It’s like finding a treasure. I appreciate how you express your many points and share in your views. Thank you.
Your original take on this topic has me thinking about many of the points you shared in this article. This is great content with substance.
I am very curious as to where this writer learned to write. This writing is very impressive and gripping. I hope this writer post more informative articles much like this one. They are utterly fantastic.
Oddly enough, the points made in this article are much like my thoughts on this subject. It’s a little weird to see views much like my own in written content. I like this a lot.
I admire your dedication to excellence. Your content is very obviously well-researched. I got so involved in your article that I couldn’t even make myself quit reading. Thank you for producing such great quality work.
I have a project that I am just now working on, and I have been looking for such information… Regards
Usually when I read, my mind wanders. Your article kept me absorbed. I couldn’t take my eyes off your material because it is so engrossing.
I appreciate well-written and informative content. This article shows the writer’s knowledge of the subject matter as well as masterful writing skills. I enjoyed this article and will return for more very soon. Thank you.
Great post. Thanks for the helpful cheat sheets. Now maybe I’ll get my head wrapped around this stuff. Probably not, but it’s a goal. Gotta have them goals.
This is very interesting information. I agree with a lot of this content. I like this article very much and I have enjoyed reading your points of interest. Thank you.
I have never seen such good content online before. You have really earned my deepest respect. I have shared this with my friends because it deserves to be seen. You are truly a good writer.
Passion in what one believes and in putting it in writing is a true talent. This particular article has the perfect combination of passion and excellent material wrapped up into an easy to comprehend article.
implementing bank card meant for small business can be veruy uncomfortable in some cases. considering after i have cash, charge card carries a cap.
I feel the need to thank you for your great writing ability and unique content. Your article reflects many of my same views. You have written some very interesting content.
Seldom am I satisfied with the quality of the online content I read today. This happens to be just the material I like to read because it makes me think.
Great article! I can’t express how much I enjoyed reading this material. I think you have hit home with this information. Thank you so much.
This article has inspired me to begin writing on things similar to what you have here. I hope you continue to work on things like this. It’s a big help.
Your writing style is phenomenal as is your information in this article. You managed to keep things upbeat and engaging here while giving your readers some things to think about.
I recently read some articles that were so dull and off center that I couldn’t abide finishing them. Your article is not one of those articles. I like your content.
It’s an honor to read good quality content like you have written here. You have proven your true writing talent and presented your views well.
Your work is very inspiring. This article is material that is absorbing and interesting. The points made here are original. I hope you continue this. Your work surpasses my expectations.
This is some of the best material I’ve read in a long time. You’ve really hit on some solid points in my opinion. I agree with you. Don’t quit rolling out great content like this.
This article is an excellent example of writing that all my students should be emulating. You have captured the essence of the subject with detail-oriented information, yet kept it understandable.
I wish I had found this article sooner. It would have saved me from the confusing data I had to read on this topic. Thank you for clearing things up for me. I appreciate it.