On July 20, 2010 a single Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee voted approval of Elena Kagan to be the fourth female associate justice ever to serve on the Supreme Court.
The vote was 13-6 with Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) breaking party ranks to vote approval. Senator Graham explained his approval vote:
“What’s in Elena Kagan’s heart is that of a good person who adopts a philosophy I disagree with,” Graham said. “She will serve this nation honorably, and it would not have been someone I would have chosen, but the person who did choose, President Obama, I think chose wisely.”
Elena Kagan has served as Obama’s Solicitor General, the highest-ranking trial lawyer in the country. She has had limited courtroom experience, but her greatest attributes were noted in an open endorsement letter from sixty-nine deans of law schools and includes an “understanding of both doctrine and policy” as well as her written record of legal analysis.
Kagan will be the third female associate justice currently serving on the Supreme Court and would be the first associate justice since 1972 without any prior bench time as a judge. The last justice with that experience record was William Rehnquist, who rose to spend 19 years as Chief Justice and administered the oath of office to three separate presidents (two of them twice).
Republicans fear that Kagan will put her political views and her liberal agenda ahead of the law. Senator Orrin Hatch (R-UT) said, “Ms. Kagan’s record shows that she supports an activist judicial philosophy, and that her personal and political views drive her legal views.”
Republicans were swift to declare their opposition to Kagan, more than they were with last year’s Supreme Court nominee, Sonia Sotomayor. It comes at a time when November elections are drawing focus, and Republicans are working to polarize themselves from Democratic actions.
Conservative political groups pressured Republican senators to oppose Kagan’s nomination. The National Rifle Association (NRA) urged their campaign beneficiaries to vote “no” or stage a filibuster to block Kagan outright and threatened to downgrade contributions to Kagan supporters. This results from her time when she tried to block military recruiters from campus as Dean of the Harvard Law School.
Senator Graham was the only Republican to publicly announce he would vote to approve, although four other Republicans joined him crossing the party line for the full confirmation vote. Other than those few, Republicans marched in lock step to their party’s orders.
Graham’s decision to support Obama’s Supreme Court nominee makes it increasingly likely he will face a primary challenge by his own party when he’s up for re-election in 2014. South Carolina political gurus say the Senator’s support for Kagan “ensures he will face a serious primary challenge”
“It’s a tough political environment out there,” stated Graham.
It is indeed tough when Members of Congress are more interested in their own reelection than voting what’s best for the people who elected them, and blindly obeying orders to receive support in their next election.
~~~~~
On August 5, 2010, on the eve of the Congressional vacation, 36 GOP Senators and one Democrat — Senator Ben Nelson of Nebraska – voted against the Supreme Court confirmation of Elena Kagan. Aside from the lockstep robot Republicans, five broke ranks to vote confirmation — Senators Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe of Maine, Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, Richard Lugar of Indiana and Judd Gregg of New Hampshire.
Republican opponents spouted lame excuses for their ‘nay’ vote, like her opposition to military recruiters on the Harvard campus (when they were allowed access everywhere else), her opinion in a single case in her legal history, and her lack of courtroom experience as a judge.
The major reason shared by all who opposed her seemed to be the fear that she will use her own judgement in deciding issues. Those opponents need to read the U.S. Constitution; interpretation is why we have a Supreme Court.
They really fear that she will put her politics ahead of the law and be a rubber stamp for Obama’s agenda.
~~~~~
Similar treatment was given to Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor. She was only the second jurist to be nominated to three different judicial positions by three different presidents but was still voted against by Republicans.
See: Republicans against Obama nominee Sonia Sotomayor
I really can have these sharing for the better usage. Really needed these posting. And I have bookmarked this post.
Awesome article, I am regular visitor of this website, keep up the good work, and I will be a regular visitor for a very long time.
I don’t commonly add comments to any kind of content online, but this article deserves my attention. For what it’s worth, you’ve done a fantastic job of getting across your points and I’m with you.
Have you ever considered writing an e-book or guest authoring on other websites? I have a blog based on the same topics you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information. I know my viewers would enjoy your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to send me an email.
It’s very gratifying to see that your article supports my own viewpoints. I couldn’t have written this better myself. Your standard of excellent writing has to be high to produce this kind of quality article.
I really like to read an article that confirms there are writers that can get their point across without confusing their readers. You have done an excellent job with this.
This article is superb! I read your article and thought I’d tell you that I think your presentation is excellent and your views are right on track. I can’t imagine anyone putting this together better.
The comments expressed in this article are very organized and thoughtful. This is also very easy to read and understand.
I like how you wrote this. You have made your points with unique thoughts and content. Your points are so clear and concise your readers can determine what they agree with and what they don’t.
This article validates that there are conscientious writers who do their homework before writing. You have great insight in this subject matter. I respect that.
Your article is excellent. Your writing style and solid information is interesting and smart. I agree with a lot of your views. Thank you for your dedication to quality content.
Ive got to say, the layout alone made me come back to this blog again. But now that Ive read what youve got to say, Ive got to share it with the world!
What an intriguing and thought provoking article. You have raised my overall awareness with your well written thoughts. I will continue to use the valuable information from this article for years to come. Thank you.
Opposing views are a great way to write such an interesting informative article. Your word choices and dictation have made this such an enjoyable article to read, producing quite a thought process along the way.
I know there’s more to writing informational articles like this than typing some words. I get that you did a lot of work on this content. I think it’s impressive.
This is a very informative reading. You’ve really gotten my interest on many points. I agree with most of your points and am presently examining the rest. Thank you for keeping your writing so interesting.
I personally think your article is awesome! I am intrigued with much of your information and am persuaded to agree with you after reading your material. I’m hoping you’ll add more articles on this topic.
I can’t match some of the great comments here, but I do know you’re a wonderful writer with a unique perspective. Thank you for sharing.
If this article hasn’t been posted anywhere else, it should be. You have definitely learned much from the ideas you came up with to put into such a wonderful article.
Im a huge fan already, man. Youve done a brilliant job making sure that people understand where youre coming from. And let me tell you, I get it. Great stuff and I cant wait to read more of your blogs. What youve got to say is important and needs to be read.
This article is worthy of all the great comments already made. I just want to add my two cents into the mix. This is valuable content with dead-on sensible points.
This is a lot of information to take in, but I am enjoying the thought process. I really am impressed with your article. Thank you.
I’m glad I read this content. Your info is thought-provoking and practical. I am sure it will be very useful for me in my studies.
It isn’t very often an article interests me enough to get engrossed in the information. This kept me interested from start to finish. Thank you.
Excellent job on this article. I like your representation of your views. I would also like to thank you for interesting reading on this topic.
This is a great article loaded with unique information. I really enjoyed the content and agree with most of your views. Thank you for sharing.
I have a hard time describing my thoughts on content, but I really felt I should here. Your article is really great. I like the way you wrote this information.
That is some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions could be this varied.
How you managed to take this informative article and turn it into an interesting piece of writing is simply amazing to me. I am very impressed with your writing abilities. I am bookmarking this content.
While reading the article, I could envision the writer sitting alone thinking. I can tell that you worked very hard on this article. Thank you.
This is a good post, but I was wondering how do I suscribe to the RSS feed?
Your article is splendid. I’ve really enjoyed reading it and reviewing the points you’ve made. Thank you for presenting this useful information in an easy to read and understand format.
I think you did an awesome job explaining it. Sure beats having to research it on my own. Thanks
Fresh ideas aren’t seen much these days. With the fear of putting something in print and being called out-of-touch, I’m glad to see someone so in touch with their beliefs.
I can’t come close to expressing my respect for your content like other readers, but I do know I enjoyed reading your article. Thank you.
I am not a professional writer, but I do realize great work when I see it. Your content is of high quality and your standards are at a high bar.
Great information here, let me share with you a complete rehab and prehab system that works for all the various kinds of sprained ankles
I am a thinking person. This article makes a lot of sense as well as igniting great thought. You are a writer with a knack for making your content interesting.
I feel for writers and the work they have to do for quality writing. You have obviously done a lot of work on this. Your writing style makes this interesting.
It’s evident to me that this article is designed to attract thinkers and provoke thought. I found this content to be interesting, digestible and well-written.
It’s nice to see that you have researched this topic, provided good quality information and presented interesting points that compel your readers to think. I appreciate the effort you put into your content. Thank you.
Completely understand what your stance in this matter. Although I would disagree on some of the finer details
Impressive! I am amazed at how well you use words to get your point across. I would be interested in reading more of your work.
I have been surfing the web with my iPhone and came across your site. I just wanted to let you know it looks great on a mobile device. I will definitely bookmark your site to come back and view it again.
I was really surprised to see the angle you took to produce this article. It is refreshing and first rate. You must continue to find these kind of ideas and produce more well written articles.
I plan to reread your article later to think on your unique ideas. Your article is very persuasive. It’s already in my favorite’s folder so I can quickly access it.
I’m impressed with your ideas and the way you express them in this article. I share many of your views and enjoyed reading this article. It’s a pleasure to see well-written original content these days.
This article is an appealing wealth of informative data that is interesting and well-written. I commend your hard work on this and thank you for this information. You’ve got what it takes to get attention.
This is a very good article! Thanks for making this information interesting. I enjoyed this article a lot and I share many of your views.
I can’t match some of the great comments here, but I do know you’re a wonderful writer with a unique perspective. Thank you for sharing.